By Sarah Thorpe
There is a particular moment that comes for a lot of women I speak to. It doesn’t arrive dramatically. It tends to surface during something mundane. A commute, a shower, the ten minutes between one thing and the next.
The moment is this: something at work no longer feels right. And almost immediately, two stories rush in to explain it.
The first story is generous. It says: something has shifted. The environment, what it asks you to absorb, overlook, or perform, has started to cost more than it gives back. The version of success on offer no longer fits the person you’ve become. This isn’t weakness or disengagement. It’s discernment. Your values doing their job.
The second story is less kind. It says: something is wrong with you. You’re not resilient enough. Not strategic enough. Not thick-skinned enough. Other people manage it. You should be able to manage it too.
The cruel thing is that both stories can feel equally available, often on the same day.
In the steadier moments, the first story is obvious. Of course it’s the system. Of course this isn’t about capability. You have spent years demonstrating that.
In the harder moments, the second story moves in and starts to feel like the truth. The tired moments. The ones where you have absorbed one thing too many, where you are running low on the kind of energy that clarity requires, where the gap between how things look from the outside and how they actually feel on the inside has been widening for longer than you’d like to admit.
I want to say something about that second story, because I think it deserves more attention than it usually gets.
I can tell you exactly where I was the first time I knew a role was no longer working for me. The recognition was like a ping on a piece of glass. Sometimes I heard it immediately. Sometimes I only understood it in retrospect. But what I can tell you is that narrative two always shouted louder than narrative one. Every time. The values signal was there. The deficiency story was louder.
It is not irrational. It is not a sign of low self-esteem or poor self-knowledge. It is, in many ways, a logical response to years of operating inside a system whose unwritten rules were largely written by and for someone else. When you have spent long enough inside a frame that doesn’t quite fit, the frame starts to feel like reality. Its standards start to feel like your standards. Its measure of success starts to feel like the only measure.
So when you find yourself falling short of something, when the cost of playing the game starts to outweigh the reward, the most available explanation is often that the failure is yours. Not the system’s. Not the environment’s. Yours.
This is where I think the most important coaching work happens. Not in the cheerful territory of goals and action plans. In the quieter, harder territory of learning to notice which story has arrived and not mistaking one for the other.
Because they are not the same thing, even when they feel identical.
Exhaustion wearing clarity’s clothes is still exhaustion. A values signal wearing the costume of personal failure is still a values signal.
The work is not choosing between the two stories once and being done with it. It is building the capacity to notice, in real time, which one is speaking. To ask: is this actually what I think, or is this what I think when I’m running low?
That distinction sounds simple. In practice, for women who have been high-performing and high-functioning for a long time, it is one of the most disorienting things to sit with. Because these women are good at thinking clearly under pressure. They have built careers on it. The idea that their own thinking might be compromised, not by a crisis, just by accumulated depletion, can itself feel like evidence for the second story.
It is not. It is evidence that they are human. And that they have been carrying a great deal, for a long time, without adequate space to put it down and look at it.
That is not a character flaw. It is a very common situation that deserves more honest conversation than it gets.